Looking Beyond the RYOBI P1818 18-Volt ONE+ Lithium-Ion? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
Explore 6 alternatives to the RYOBI P1818 18 volt one lithium ion. We compare published specs like voltage, tool count, and battery capacity to help you choose.
By GaugeKit Editorial Team 6 min read
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
If you are considering ryobi p1818 18 volt one lithium ion alternatives, you should first look at what the original kit offers. The Ryobi P1818 is a 4-tool cordless set that includes two 18-Volt batteries and a charger. It provides a complete starter collection for hobbyists building an 18-Volt ecosystem. The four-tool configuration and included bag make it a practical choice for general home use.
However, you might need different specifications for your specific projects. Some users require higher voltage for more power, while others prefer a smaller kit size for better portability. Others may prioritize brushless motors for efficiency or specific tool combinations like hammer drills. The 6 alternatives listed here were chosen because their specs overlap with the original Ryobi kit. Each option offers a distinct balance of voltage, tool count, and form factor to suit different needs.
How each alternative compares
CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit
The Craftsman V20 MAX 4-Tool Kit matches the Ryobi P1818 with a complete four-tool set, including an impact driver, circular saw, drill driver, and work light. It distinguishes itself with a 6-1/2-inch blade diameter for the saw and a 1/2-inch chuck size, offering robust torque and cutting speed. At 16.9 pounds, it is heavier than the Ryobi kit, which includes a bag. This option suits budget-conscious DIYers who need a full set rather than specialized, lighter tools. It trades the Ryobi’s compact ecosystem for higher raw power and a broader tool selection in a single purchase.
Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit
The Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit reduces the tool count to two but increases specialization. It includes a hammer drill and an impact driver, designed for heavy-duty drilling and fastening. Weighing 11.2 pounds, it is lighter than the Craftsman kit but focuses on power density. This kit fits professionals who prioritize battery life and drilling capability over having a large variety of tools. It lacks the circular saw and work light found in the Ryobi P1818, making it a choice for users who need robust performance in fewer, more powerful tools rather than a broad starter collection.
FLEX 24V Brushless Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit
The FLEX 24V Brushless Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit offers a higher voltage platform at 24V compared to the Ryobi’s 18-Volt system. It features brushless motors and a 2.5 Ah battery capacity, providing high torque in a compact package. This 2-tool kit includes an impact driver and drill driver, omitting the saw and light found in the Ryobi set. It suits users who prioritize power density and self-tapping features over kit size. The compact form factor and advanced motor technology make it ideal for compact high-torque tasks, appealing to those who need performance in tight spaces.
Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit
The Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit matches the Ryobi’s 18V voltage but focuses on portability. It includes a brushless drill driver and impact driver, weighing only 2.9 pounds. This sub-compact design reduces fatigue and fits easily into small workspaces. It lacks the four-tool variety of the Ryobi P1818, offering only two tools with a 1.5Ah battery capacity. This kit is best for users who prioritize portability and durability over battery life and kit size. It is a practical choice for those who need lightweight, durable tools for confined areas rather than a comprehensive starter set.
DEWALT 20V MAX Drill and Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit
The DEWALT 20V MAX Drill and Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit shifts the tool selection away from standard drilling and cutting. It includes a drill driver and an oscillating multi-tool, both running on a 20V platform with a 2.0 Ah battery. This 2-tool kit weighs 8.2 pounds, offering compact maneuverability and versatile multi-tool speed. It lacks the impact driver, circular saw, and work light included in the Ryobi P1818. This option suits users who value specialized versatility and compact design over a larger battery count or a traditional four-tool selection, making it ideal for detailed work and tight spaces.
DEWALT 20V MAX Drill, Impact Driver and Work Light Kit
The DEWALT 20V MAX Drill, Impact Driver and Work Light Kit offers a three-tool configuration, one tool less than the Ryobi P1818. It includes an impact driver, drill driver, and work light, running on a 20V platform. Weighing 9.4 pounds, it emphasizes portability and tight-space access. This kit omits the circular saw found in the Ryobi set, focusing on core fastening and lighting needs. It is ideal for compact projects requiring portability. Users who prioritize access in confined areas over a larger battery count or a four-tool selection will find this kit a practical, focused alternative to the broader Ryobi collection.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | RYOBI 18V 4-Tool Cordless Kit Best overall | Starting an 18-Volt tool collection | |
| 2 | CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit Best budget | budget-conscious DIYers needing a full 4-tool set | |
| 3 | Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit Best hammer drill | Heavy-duty drilling and fastening tasks | |
| 4 | FLEX 24V Brushless Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit Best premium | compact high-torque tasks | |
| 5 | Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit Best 18v | compact workspaces and fatigue reduction | |
| 6 | DEWALT 20V MAX Drill and Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit Best 2.0 ah | Compact drills and oscillating tools | |
| 7 | DEWALT 20V MAX Drill, Impact Driver and Work Light Kit Best 3-tool | compact projects requiring portability |
RYOBI 18V 4-Tool Cordless Kit
Best for: Starting an 18-Volt tool collection
- Voltage
- 18-Volt
- Kit Size
- 4-Tool
- Battery Count
- 2
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Configuration
- Kit
The Ryobi P1818 is an 18-Volt cordless kit containing four tools, two batteries, a charger, and a bag. It uses the ONE+ system, letting you share batteries across many tools. You get two batteries for rotation. The four-tool set covers basic needs. This bundle suits those starting a collection or needing a versatile starter set.
- Includes four distinct tools in one package
- Comes with two 18-Volt batteries
- Includes a dedicated charger and carrying bag
- Fewer tools in the kit compared to 6-tool alternatives
- Lower voltage system than 20V or 24V competitors
- You want a single bundle to start your tool collection
- You prefer the 18-Volt ONE+ battery ecosystem
- You need a portable kit with a bag included
- You require higher voltage for heavy-duty cutting
- You need more than four tools in the initial purchase
- You already own a 20V or 24V battery platform
Verdict: Ryobi 18-Volt 4-Tool Combo Kit offers a complete starter set with two batteries and a bag. It fits hobbyists building an 18-Volt collection rather than pros needing high-power 20V tools.
CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit
Best for: budget-conscious DIYers needing a full 4-tool set
- Voltage
- 20V MAX
- Kit Size
- 4-tool
- Included Tools
- Drill, impact, circular saw, task light
- Chuck Size
- 1/2 Inch
- Blade Diameter
- 6-1/2 Inch
- Power Source
- Cordless
This Craftsman V20 MAX 4-tool kit includes a 1/2-inch drill, impact driver, circular saw, and LED work light. The drill delivers 280 UWO with a 2-speed gearbox. The impact driver provides 1,460 in-lbs of torque. The circular saw features a 6-1/2-inch blade running at 4,200 RPM. It is a solid option for users needing a versatile, budget-friendly cordless system for general home projects.
- 1,460 in-lbs of torque on the impact driver
- 280 UWO power output from the 1/2-inch drill
- 4,200 RPM blade speed on the circular saw
- Includes a 140-lumen pivoting LED task light
- Heavier build at 16.9 pounds compared to sub-compact alternatives
- 20V MAX voltage is lower than the 24V or 20V MAX options from competitors like FLEX and DEWALT
- Standard brushed motor technology instead of brushless efficiency found in other kits
- You need a complete 4-tool set for basic home repairs
- You want a circular saw with a 6-1/2-inch blade for ripping 2x material
- You prefer a 2-speed gearbox for varied drilling tasks
- You require brushless motors for maximum runtime and durability
- You need a sub-compact or lighter tool configuration
- You are looking for a higher voltage system like 24V or 20V MAX from DEWALT
Verdict: Craftsman V20 MAX 4-Tool Kit offers strong torque and cutting speed for a budget-conscious buyer who values a complete kit over specialized, lighter tools.
Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit
Best for: Heavy-duty drilling and fastening tasks
- Voltage
- 18-Volt
- Kit Size
- 2
- Included Tools
- Hammer drill driver, impact driver
- Battery Count
- 2
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Configuration
- Kit
This 18-volt kit includes a 1/2-inch hammer drill driver and a 1/4-inch hex compact impact driver. It comes with two M18 REDLITHIUM XC batteries and a multi-voltage charger. The package weighs 11.2 pounds and measures 17.9 inches in length. It suits users who need durable, high-torque tools for heavy-duty fastening and drilling tasks on job sites.
- Includes 1/2-inch hammer drill driver for masonry work
- Features 1/4-inch hex compact impact driver for fastening
- Comes with two M18 REDLITHIUM XC extended capacity batteries
- Includes M18 and M12 multi-voltage charger
- Heavier build at 11.2 pounds compared to sub-compact options
- Larger overall length of 17.9 inches reduces portability
- Fewer tools in the kit with only two included
- You need a hammer drill for masonry applications
- You want extended capacity batteries for longer runtime
- You prefer a durable contractor bag for storage
- You require a sub-compact design for tight spaces
- You need more than two tools in the kit
- You prefer lighter weight tools for overhead work
Verdict: Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit delivers robust power for demanding tasks. It fits professionals who prioritize battery life and drilling capability over compact size.
FLEX 24V Brushless Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit
Best for: compact high-torque tasks
- Voltage
- 24V
- Kit Size
- 2
- Included Tools
- Hammer drill, impact driver
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Capacity
- 2.5Ah
- Battery Count
- 2
The FLEX 24V Brushless 2-Tool Combo Kit includes a hammer drill and impact driver. It features brushless motors for efficiency and delivers 1,000 in-lbs of torque on the drill and 1,900 in-lbs on the driver. The kit comes with two 2.5Ah batteries and a 75W charger. This setup suits users who need high torque in a compact form factor for tight spaces.
- Brushless motor technology
- 1,900 in-lbs impact driver torque
- Self-tapping screw mode
- Compact 6.1-inch height
- 2.5Ah battery capacity is smaller than typical 4.0Ah or 5.0Ah options
- Only two tools in the kit compared to 4-tool or 6-tool sets
- You need high torque in a compact tool
- You prefer a 24V system
- You work in tight spaces
- You need a large battery capacity
- You want a multi-tool combo
- You require a 18V system
Verdict: FLEX 24V Brushless 2-Tool Combo offers high torque in a compact package. It fits users who prioritize power density and self-tapping features over kit size.
Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit
Best for: compact workspaces and fatigue reduction
- Voltage
- 18V
- Kit Size
- 2-Pc.
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Capacity
- 1.5Ah
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Form Factor
- Compact
This Makita 18V LXT kit includes a sub-compact brushless driver-drill and impact driver. The tool weighs 2.9 lbs with battery and measures 5-7/8 inches long. It features a 1.5Ah battery and delivers 350 in.lbs. of peak torque. You get a two-speed transmission with 0-500 and 0-1,700 RPM settings. This setup suits users who need lightweight, compact tools for tight spaces.
- Brushless motor delivers 350 in.lbs. of peak torque
- Lightweight design at 2.9 lbs with battery
- Compact length of 5-7/8 inches
- Metal jam pot design for durability
- Small 1.5Ah battery capacity limits runtime
- Only includes two tools in the kit
- You need a lightweight tool to reduce operator fatigue
- You work in tight spaces requiring a compact form factor
- You prefer brushless motor efficiency
- You require a larger battery capacity for extended use
- You need more than two tools in the kit
Verdict: Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit offers high torque in a small package. It fits users who prioritize portability and durability over battery life and kit size.
DEWALT 20V MAX Drill and Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit
Best for: Compact drills and oscillating tools
- Voltage
- 20V MAX
- Kit Size
- 2 Tool
- Included Tools
- Drill Driver, Oscillating Multi-Tool
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Capacity
- 2 Ah
- Battery Count
- 2
This DEWALT kit includes a brushless drill driver and an oscillating multi-tool. It comes with two 20V MAX 2 Ah batteries and a charger. The drill features a compact design for tight spaces. The oscillating tool offers 20,000 OPM and three speed settings. This setup suits users needing versatile power tools with reliable runtime for general projects.
- Brushless motor for long runtime
- Includes two 2 Ah batteries
- Oscillating tool reaches 20,000 OPM
- Compact drill design for tight areas
- Three speed selections on multi-tool
- Lower battery capacity at 2 Ah compared to 4 Ah options
- Smaller 2-tool kit size versus 4-tool competitors
- Heavier build at 8.2 pounds
- You need a compact drill for tight spaces
- You want an oscillating tool with variable speeds
- You prefer a reliable 20V MAX system
- You require a 4-tool combo kit
- You need high-capacity batteries over 2 Ah
- You prefer lighter tools under 8 pounds
Verdict: DEWALT 20V MAX 2-Tool Combo Kit fits users who value compact maneuverability and versatile multi-tool speed. It is ideal for those who do not need a large battery capacity or a four-tool selection.
DEWALT 20V MAX Drill, Impact Driver and Work Light Kit
Best for: compact projects requiring portability
- Voltage
- 20V MAX
- Kit Size
- 3
- Included Tools
- Drill, impact driver, LED work light
- Battery Count
- 2
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Form Factor
- Portable
This DEWALT 3-tool combo kit includes a drill, impact driver, and LED work light. The drill delivers 300 unit watts out for varied applications. The impact driver measures 5.55 inches front to back and weighs 2.8 lbs. You get two batteries with this portable setup. The design fits into tight areas. It suits users needing compact tools for confined spaces.
- Drill delivers 300 unit watts out
- Impact driver is 5.55 inches long
- Includes LED work light
- Comes with two batteries
- Kit weighs 9.4 pounds total
- Only includes two batteries
- You need a drill with 300 unit watts out
- You work in tight spaces requiring compact tools
- You want a portable 3-tool setup
- You require more than two batteries
- You need a tool heavier than 9.4 pounds
- You prefer a 20V MAX brushless motor
Verdict: DEWALT 20V MAX 3-Tool Portable Kit offers solid power in a compact form. It fits users who prioritize portability and tight-space access over high battery counts.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | RYOBI 18V 4-Tool Cordless Kit | CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit | Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit | FLEX 24V Brushless Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit | Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit | DEWALT 20V MAX Drill and Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit | DEWALT 20V MAX Drill, Impact Driver and Work Light Kit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 18-Volt | 20V MAX | 18-Volt | 24V | 18V | 20V MAX | 20V MAX |
| Kit Size | 4-Tool | 4-tool | 2 | 2 | 2-Pc. | 2 Tool | 3 |
| Included Tools | – | Drill, impact, circular saw, task light | Hammer drill driver, impact driver | Hammer drill, impact driver | – | Drill Driver, Oscillating Multi-Tool | Drill, impact driver, LED work light |
| Motor Type | – | – | – | Brushless | Brushless | Brushless | – |
| Battery Capacity | – | – | – | 2.5Ah | 1.5Ah | 2 Ah | – |
| Battery Count | 2 | – | 2 | 2 | – | 2 | 2 |
| Chuck Size | – | 1/2 Inch | – | 1/2 Inch | – | – | – |
| Blade Diameter | – | 6-1/2 Inch | – | – | – | – | – |
| Speed | – | – | – | Two-Speed | – | – | – |
| Power Source | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless |
| Form Factor | – | – | – | – | Compact | – | Portable |
| Configuration | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit |
| Dimensions | – | 19 × 9.6 × 11.5 inches | 17.9 × 4.72 × 11.2 inches | – | 9.25 × 13 × 9.88 inches | 13.1 × 5.12 × 8.94 inches | 15 × 6.3 × 9.8 inches |
| Weight | – | 16.9 pounds | 11.2 pounds | – | 2.9 pounds | 8.2 pounds | 9.4 pounds |
| Model | P1818 | CMCK401D2 | 2797-22xc | FXM209-2A | CX203SYB | DCK251D2 | DCK3XXX2 |
| Color | – | – | Black Red | – | Black Blue | Black, Yellow | Multi |
| Size | – | – | – | – | – | 2 Tool Combo Kit | One Size |
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative offers the most tools for a complete starter set?
The RYOBI 18V 4-Tool Kit and the CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Kit both provide four tools. The Ryobi option includes two batteries and a bag, making it ideal for hobbyists. The Craftsman kit features a circular saw with a 6-1/2-inch blade and an impact driver. Both offer a full set for building a new tool collection without specialized single tools.
What is the lightest option in this list?
The Makita 18V LXT Sub-Compact Brushless 2-Tool Kit is the lightest at 2.9 pounds. It is designed for compact workspaces and reduces user fatigue. The kit includes a drill driver and impact driver with 1.5Ah batteries. Its small form factor prioritizes portability and durability over larger battery capacity or a wider selection of tools.
Which kit includes an oscillating multi-tool?
The DEWALT 20V MAX Drill and Oscillating Multi-Tool Kit includes this versatile tool. It pairs a drill driver with an oscillating multi-tool for flexible tasks. The kit uses 2.0 Ah batteries and weighs 8.2 pounds. It suits users who value compact maneuverability and multi-tool speed over a larger four-tool selection or higher battery capacity.
Are there brushless motor options available?
Yes, the FLEX 24V and Makita 18V kits feature brushless motors. The FLEX model offers high torque in a compact 24V package with a two-speed transmission. The Makita sub-compact kit also uses brushless technology for efficiency. These motors generally provide longer runtime and durability compared to brushed alternatives, fitting users who prioritize power density and tool life.
Which option is best for heavy-duty drilling tasks?
The Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit is built for demanding tasks. It includes a hammer drill capable of robust power for drilling and fastening. The 2-tool kit weighs 11.2 pounds and prioritizes battery life and drilling capability. It fits professionals who need durable performance in tight spaces or heavy-use scenarios over compact size.
What is the smallest voltage platform here?
The FLEX 24V Brushless Kit operates on a 24V platform, which is higher than the 18V and 20V options. However, it delivers high torque in a compact package. The RYOBI and Makita kits use 18V, while Craftsman and DEWALT use 20V. The FLEX system suits users who prioritize power density and self-tapping features over a larger number of included tools.
Which kit is best for tight spaces?
The DEWALT 20V MAX Drill, Impact Driver and Work Light Kit is designed for portability and tight-space access. It weighs 9.4 pounds and includes a work light for visibility. The compact form factor allows for easy maneuvering in confined areas. It suits users who prioritize access and portability over high battery counts or a larger four-tool selection.
See also
Where to buy
at Amazon
Price taken from the listing when this page was written and it can change at any time. We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.
More Power Tool Combo Kits
See the sectionGet our picks by email
New reviews and the prices we spotted, once a week.











