Looking Beyond the RYOBI P1896 ONE Plus 18-Volt? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look
Explore 6 ryobi p1896 one plus 18 volt alternatives. We compare published specifications like weight, tool count, and battery capacity to help you choose the right kit.
By GaugeKit Editorial Team 6 min read
As Amazon Associates, we earn from qualifying purchases. This means we may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you if you click through and make a purchase.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
Looking beyond the RYOBI P1896 ONE Plus 18-Volt? You should consider ryobi p1896 one plus 18 volt alternatives if the current model does not match your needs. This 12-tool kit offers a broad range of tools for general home projects. It provides a complete set for users who value variety. The kit weighs 63 pounds and measures 34 by 20 by 14 inches. This size requires significant storage space. You might want a more compact option. A smaller kit saves space and reduces weight. You may also prefer a different voltage or motor type. Some users need specialized tools for woodworking or masonry. The alternatives were chosen because their specs overlap with the original. Each option offers a different balance of tool count and portability. You can find kits with fewer tools but better ergonomics. Some models feature brushless motors for increased efficiency. Others focus on specific tasks like drilling or cutting. Your choice depends on which specifications matter most to you.
How the Alternatives Compare
CRAFTSMAN V20 Drill and Impact Driver Kit
The CRAFTSMAN V20 Drill and Impact Driver Kit focuses on portability and basic tasks. It includes only two tools: a drill driver and an impact driver. The box measures 12.3 by 4.96 by 8.86 inches and weighs 8.2 pounds. This is far smaller than the 63-pound Ryobi kit. You get a 2.0 Ah battery instead of the larger capacity often found in bigger sets. This choice suits users who need just a drill and driver for light repairs. You save significant storage space. You give up the variety of twelve tools. Pick this if you want a compact, affordable starter set for simple home projects.
Makita 18V LXT Compact 2-Tool Combo Kit
The Makita 18V LXT Compact 2-Tool Combo Kit prioritizes lightweight handling. It includes a drill and impact driver in a compact form factor. The kit weighs only 11.2 pounds and measures 13 by 9.25 by 9.88 inches. This is much smaller than the Ryobi’s 63-pound box. You get 1.5Ah batteries, which are lighter but hold less charge. The ergonomic handles reduce fatigue during extended use. This kit is ideal for users who value maneuverability in tight spaces. You trade a large tool collection for ease of use. Choose this if you need high torque in a small package without the bulk of a full system.
DEWALT 20V MAX Brushless 3-Tool Woodworking Kit
The DEWALT 20V MAX Brushless 3-Tool Woodworking Kit targets specialized tasks. It includes a sander and other woodworking tools rather than general-purpose drills. The voltage is 20V, slightly higher than the Ryobi’s 18V. The kit uses brushless motors for efficiency. The box measures 16.2 by 10.2 by 9.6 inches. It is lighter and smaller than the Ryobi’s large container. This set fits woodworkers who need a router and saws. You do not get a heavy-duty drill or impact driver. Pick this if you focus on woodworking projects. You sacrifice general utility for specialized performance in a more compact form.
CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit
The CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit offers a middle ground. It includes four tools: an impact driver, circular saw, drill driver, and work light. The box weighs 16.9 pounds and measures 19 by 9.6 by 11.5 inches. This is significantly lighter than the 63-pound Ryobi kit. You get a 6-1/2 Inch circular saw blade and a 1/2 Inch chuck. The kit provides essential functionality for basic home repair and light construction. You give up the extensive variety of the 12-tool set. Choose this if you want core tools without the bulk. It is practical for users who prioritize essential capabilities over a comprehensive collection.
DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Combo Kit
The DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Combo Kit is a comprehensive solution. It includes ten tools, close to the Ryobi’s twelve. The voltage is 20V, offering slightly more power than the 18V Ryobi. All tools use brushless motors for better efficiency and runtime. The kit is designed for contractors needing a wide range of capabilities. It fits users who want many tools in one purchase. You get a broad selection without buying individual items. The Ryobi kit includes twelve tools, so you lose two tools here. Pick this if you need a nearly complete set with brushless technology. It is ideal for those who want variety and modern motor efficiency.
Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit
The Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit is a focused two-tool solution. It includes a hammer drill and an impact driver. The box weighs 11.2 pounds and measures 17.9 by 4.72 by 11.2 inches. This is much smaller and lighter than the 63-pound Ryobi kit. The hammer drill capability is key for masonry drilling and fastening tasks. You get robust battery capacity for demanding jobs. This kit suits contractors who prioritize hammer drilling over a larger tool count. You give up the variety of twelve tools. Choose this if you need specialized masonry work. It is a practical choice for users who value power and specific functionality over a broad collection.
| # | Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ryobi 12-Tool 18V Cordless Kit Best overall | Users needing a wide variety of tools | |
| 2 | CRAFTSMAN V20 Drill and Impact Driver Kit Best budget | Basic home repair and light fastening tasks | |
| 3 | Makita 18V LXT Compact 2-Tool Combo Kit Best 18v | Lightweight, high-torque compact tasks | |
| 4 | DEWALT 20V MAX Brushless 3-Tool Woodworking Kit Best premium | Woodworking tasks requiring a router and saws | |
| 5 | CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit Best 4-tool | basic home repair and light construction | |
| 6 | DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Combo Kit Also great | Users needing a wide variety of tools | |
| 7 | Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit Best hammer drill | masonry drilling and fastening tasks |
Ryobi 12-Tool 18V Cordless Kit
Best for: Users needing a wide variety of tools
- Voltage
- 18 V
- Kit Size
- 12
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Configuration
- Kit
- Dimensions
- 34 × 20 × 14 inches
- Weight
- 63 pounds
The Ryobi P1896 is a 12-tool cordless kit running on 18-volt lithium-ion power. It weighs 63 pounds and measures 34 by 20 by 14 inches in its packaging. This large set suits users who need a wide variety of tools for general home projects. You get a broad range of capabilities in one purchase, making it a comprehensive solution for basic DIY tasks.
- Includes 12 tools in the kit
- Uses standard 18-volt battery platform
- Cordless design for portability
- Comprehensive tool selection for home use
- Heavier build at 63 pounds compared to smaller kits
- Larger footprint with 34-inch length requires more storage space
- Fewer tools per dollar value compared to 10-tool sets
- You need a wide variety of tools for general home maintenance
- You prefer a single purchase for multiple projects
- You have ample storage space for a large kit
- You prioritize lightweight and compact storage solutions
- You only need a few specific tools
- You prefer brushless motor technology for higher efficiency
Verdict: Ryobi 12-Tool 18V Cordless Combo Kit offers a broad range of tools for users who value variety over compactness. It fits those who want a complete set for general home projects and have space to store the large box.
CRAFTSMAN V20 Drill and Impact Driver Kit
Best for: Basic home repair and light fastening tasks
- Voltage
- V20
- Kit Size
- Two Power Tools
- Included Tools
- Drill Driver, Impact Driver
- Battery Capacity
- 2Ah
- Battery Count
- 2
- Chuck Size
- 1/2 Inch
This CRAFTSMAN V20 kit includes a drill driver and an impact driver, each powered by a 2Ah lithium-ion battery. The drill delivers 300 UWO, while the impact driver provides up to 1,800 in-lbs of torque. You get two batteries and a charger for extended runtime. The tools feature 1/2 inch chucks and onboard LEDs for visibility. This setup suits users who need reliable basic fastening and drilling capabilities without the bulk of a larger combo kit.
- Impact driver generates up to 1,800 in-lbs of MAX torque
- Drill driver offers 300 UWO for increased power
- Kit includes two 2Ah batteries for longer runtime
- Both tools feature bright onboard LEDs
- Smaller 2Ah battery capacity limits runtime compared to higher-capacity options
- Two-tool kit size is smaller than the 12-tool or 10-tool kits listed
- Weight of 8.2 pounds includes two batteries and charger, adding bulk
- You need a compact drill and impact driver for basic tasks
- You want two batteries included for continuous work
- You prefer a simple, affordable entry into cordless tools
- You require a large variety of tools in one kit
- You need high-capacity batteries for all-day professional use
- You are looking for a brushless motor system
Verdict: CRAFTSMAN V20 2-Tool Drill and Impact Kit is a practical starter set for homeowners who need just a drill and an impact driver. It fits those who value portability and basic torque over a comprehensive tool collection.
Makita 18V LXT Compact 2-Tool Combo Kit
Best for: Lightweight, high-torque compact tasks
- Voltage
- 18V
- Kit Size
- 2-Pc.
- Included Tools
- Driver-Drill, Impact Driver
- Battery Capacity
- 1.5Ah
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Form Factor
- Compact
This Makita CT225SYX kit includes an 18V driver-drill and impact driver. The drill offers 480 in. lbs. of torque at 1,900 RPM. The impact driver delivers 1,460 in. lbs. of torque at 3,500 IPM. Both tools are compact and weigh under 3.3 lbs. with the 1.5Ah battery. You get ergonomic soft grips for comfort. This setup suits users prioritizing lightweight handling and high torque in a small package.
- Impact driver delivers 1,460 in. lbs. max torque
- Driver-drill reaches 1,900 RPM for fast drilling
- Drill weighs only 3.3 lbs. with battery
- Impact driver weighs only 2.8 lbs. with battery
- Rubberized soft grips reduce operator fatigue
- Includes only two tools in the kit
- Battery capacity is limited to 1.5Ah
- Driver-drill torque is lower at 480 in. lbs.
- You need lightweight tools for overhead work
- You prioritize high torque in a compact form
- You want ergonomic handles for extended use
- You require a larger battery capacity
- You need a multi-tool combo kit
- You prefer higher drill torque output
Verdict: Makita 18V Compact 2-Tool Kit fits users who value lightweight handling and high torque in a compact form. You get ergonomic handles for extended use without the bulk of larger kits.
DEWALT 20V MAX Brushless 3-Tool Woodworking Kit
Best for: Woodworking tasks requiring a router and saws
- Voltage
- 20V MAX*
- Kit Size
- 3
- Included Tools
- Router, orbital sander, jig saw
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Capacity
- 5.0Ah, 2.0Ah
- Battery Count
- 2
This DEWALT kit includes a brushless router, random orbital sander, and jig saw. It comes with two batteries: a 5.0Ah pack and a compact 2.0Ah pack. The brushless motors offer efficient performance and longer runtime. You get a 4 Amp charger and a contractor bag. This setup suits users needing specialized woodworking tools rather than a general drill or impact driver.
- Brushless motors for efficient runtime in the sander and jig saw
- Includes a 5.0Ah XR battery for extended capacity
- Variable-speed dial on the router for application matching
- Compact 2.0Ah battery included for lighter tasks
- Kit size is only 3 tools, fewer than the 10-tool or 12-tool kits on this list
- Includes only two batteries, whereas other kits provide more power sources
- No hammer drill included, limiting masonry work capability
- You need a router, sander, and jig saw for woodworking
- You prefer brushless motor efficiency for longer runtime
- You already have compatible 20V MAX batteries
- You require a hammer drill for masonry projects
- You want a large 10-tool or 12-tool kit
- You need a standard drill driver as the primary tool
Verdict: DEWALT 20V MAX 3-Tool Combo provides specialized woodworking tools with brushless efficiency. It fits woodworkers who need a router and saws but do not require a heavy-duty drill or impact driver.
CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit
Best for: basic home repair and light construction
- Voltage
- 20V MAX
- Kit Size
- 4-tool
- Included Tools
- Drill, impact, circular saw, task light
- Chuck Size
- 1/2 Inch
- Blade Diameter
- 6-1/2 Inch
- Power Source
- Cordless
This CRAFTSMAN V20 MAX 4-tool kit includes a drill, impact driver, circular saw, and LED task light. The drill delivers 280 UWO with a 2-speed gearbox, while the impact driver offers 1,460 in-lbs of torque. The circular saw features a 6-1/2 inch blade running at 4,200 RPM. It weighs 16.9 pounds and comes with a 3-year limited warranty. You get a focused set of tools for general construction and DIY tasks.
- Impact driver provides 1,460 in-lbs of torque
- Circular saw runs at 4,200 RPM
- LED task light outputs 140 lumens
- Includes 3-year limited warranty
- Kit size is limited to 4 tools
- Total kit weight is 16.9 pounds
- Drill speed caps at 1,500 RPM
- You need a compact set for basic home projects
- You want a circular saw included in your starter kit
- You prefer a system with a 3-year warranty
- You require more than four tools in one purchase
- You need high-speed drilling above 1,500 RPM
- You are looking for a heavy-duty 12-tool combo
Verdict: CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Kit offers a practical selection of core tools for users who prioritize essential functionality over extensive variety. It fits buyers who want a circular saw and impact driver without the bulk of a larger system.
DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Combo Kit
Best for: Users needing a wide variety of tools
- Voltage
- 20V MAX
- Kit Size
- 10
- Motor Type
- Brushless
- Battery Count
- 2
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Configuration
- Kit
This 10-tool kit offers a brushless motor platform across its cordless lineup. It includes two batteries and a charger. The tools feature compact designs for tight spaces. You get a reciprocating saw with quick blade changes. A Bluetooth speaker adds convenience. This setup suits users needing a wide variety of tools in one purchase.
- 10-tool kit size provides extensive tool coverage.
- Brushless motor type offers efficient power delivery.
- Includes two batteries for extended runtime.
- Compact 7.6-inch depth fits in tight areas.
- Wireless Bluetooth speaker runs on tool batteries.
- Only two batteries are included in the kit.
- 20V MAX voltage is lower than some competitors.
- You need a large variety of tools in one box.
- You work in tight spaces requiring compact tools.
- You want a Bluetooth speaker powered by your tools.
- You require more than two batteries for all-day work.
- You need 18V compatibility with existing Ryobi tools.
- You prefer a smaller kit with fewer tools.
Verdict: DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Kit is a comprehensive solution for those who want many tools in one purchase. It fits contractors needing a wide range of capabilities without buying individual items.
Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit
Best for: masonry drilling and fastening tasks
- Voltage
- 18-Volt
- Kit Size
- 2
- Included Tools
- Hammer drill driver, impact driver
- Battery Count
- 2
- Power Source
- Cordless
- Configuration
- Kit
This Milwaukee M18 kit includes an 18-volt hammer drill and an impact driver. It comes with two REDLITHIUM XC batteries and a multi-voltage charger. The set weighs 11.2 pounds and fits in a contractor bag. You get a 1/2-inch drill and a 1/4-inch hex driver. This setup suits professionals who need reliable cordless power for drilling and fastening tasks on site.
- Includes 1/2-inch hammer drill driver
- Includes 1/4-inch hex compact impact driver
- Comes with two M18 REDLITHIUM XC batteries
- Features an M18 and M12 multi-voltage charger
- Kit size is only two tools, fewer than the twelve-tool RYOBI option
- Total weight is 11.2 pounds, which is heavier than the two-tool CRAFTSMAN V20 kit
- Battery count is two, which is lower than the ten-tool DEWALT set
- You need a dedicated hammer drill for masonry work
- You want an 18-volt system with extended capacity batteries
- You prefer a compact kit that fits in a contractor bag
- You require a large multi-tool combo kit with ten or more tools
- You are looking for the lightest possible cordless drill option
- You need a 20-volt system instead of 18-volt
Verdict: Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit offers a focused two-tool solution with robust battery capacity. It fits contractors who prioritize hammer drilling capability over a larger tool count.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Ryobi 12-Tool 18V Cordless Kit | CRAFTSMAN V20 Drill and Impact Driver Kit | Makita 18V LXT Compact 2-Tool Combo Kit | DEWALT 20V MAX Brushless 3-Tool Woodworking Kit | CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit | DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Combo Kit | Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Voltage | 18 V | V20 | 18V | 20V MAX* | 20V MAX | 20V MAX | 18-Volt |
| Kit Size | 12 | Two Power Tools | 2-Pc. | 3 | 4-tool | 10 | 2 |
| Included Tools | – | Drill Driver, Impact Driver | Driver-Drill, Impact Driver | Router, orbital sander, jig saw | Drill, impact, circular saw, task light | – | Hammer drill driver, impact driver |
| Motor Type | – | – | – | Brushless | – | Brushless | – |
| Battery Capacity | – | 2Ah | 1.5Ah | 5.0Ah, 2.0Ah | – | – | – |
| Battery Count | – | 2 | – | 2 | – | 2 | 2 |
| Chuck Size | – | 1/2 Inch | – | – | 1/2 Inch | – | – |
| Blade Diameter | – | – | – | – | 6-1/2 Inch | – | – |
| Power Source | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless |
| Form Factor | – | – | Compact | – | – | – | – |
| Configuration | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit | Kit |
| Dimensions | 34 × 20 × 14 inches | 12.3 × 4.96 × 8.86 inches | 13 × 9.25 × 9.88 inches | 16.2 × 10.2 × 9.6 inches | 19 × 9.6 × 11.5 inches | – | 17.9 × 4.72 × 11.2 inches |
| Weight | 63 pounds | 8.2 pounds | – | – | 16.9 pounds | – | 11.2 pounds |
| Model | P1896 | CMCK201D2 | CT225SYX | DCK307D1P1 | CMCK401D2 | DCK1021D2 | 2797-22xc |
| Color | – | Black, Red | Black Blue | Yellow/Black | – | Black/Yellow/Sliver | Black Red |
| Size | – | – | No Size | – | – | – | – |
Frequently asked questions
Which alternative is best for basic home repair?
The CRAFTSMAN V20 Drill and Impact Driver Kit is the best budget choice for basic home repair. It includes a drill driver and an impact driver with a 2.0 Ah battery. The compact kit weighs only 8.2 pounds. This makes it easy to store and carry for light fastening tasks.
Is there a lightweight option for tight spaces?
The Makita 18V LXT Compact 2-Tool Combo Kit is designed for lightweight handling. It features a compact form factor with 1.5Ah batteries. The tools are built for high torque in small spaces. This kit is ideal for users who need ergonomic handles and do not require the bulk of larger systems.
What is the best kit for woodworking projects?
The DEWALT 20V MAX Brushless 3-Tool Woodworking Kit is the best premium option for woodworking. It includes a sander and other specialized tools with brushless motors. This kit focuses on router and saw capabilities. It is perfect for woodworkers who need precision tools without the heavy-duty drill found in other sets.
Which alternative includes a circular saw?
The CRAFTSMAN V20 4-Tool Cordless Combo Kit includes a circular saw with a 6-1/2 inch blade. It also provides an impact driver, drill driver, and work light. This 4-tool selection is practical for basic home repair and light construction. It offers essential functionality without the bulk of a larger 12-tool system.
Is there a comprehensive kit with many tools?
The DEWALT 20V MAX 10-Tool Brushless Combo Kit is a comprehensive solution for users needing a wide variety of tools. It features brushless motors for efficiency. This kit fits contractors who want many capabilities in one purchase. It allows you to avoid buying individual items while maintaining a broad tool range.
Which kit is best for masonry drilling?
The Milwaukee M18 Hammer Drill and Impact Driver Kit is the best choice for masonry drilling. It includes a hammer drill and an impact driver for robust fastening tasks. This two-tool solution offers focused capability for contractors. It prioritizes hammer drilling performance over a larger tool count, making it ideal for tough materials.
See also
Where to buy
at Amazon
Price taken from the listing when this page was written and it can change at any time. We may earn a commission if you buy through this link.
More Power Tool Combo Kits
See the sectionGet our picks by email
New reviews and the prices we spotted, once a week.











